Why Homeowners Are Ditching Their Tubs for Walk-In Showers
Here’s the thing about bathtubs — most people don’t actually use them. Sure, the idea of a relaxing soak sounds nice. But honestly? That tub just sits there collecting dust and taking up valuable space. If this sounds like your bathroom situation, you’re not alone.
Converting a bathtub to a walk-in shower has become one of the most popular bathroom updates over the past few years. And it makes sense. You get more usable space, easier access, and a cleaner modern look. Whether you’re thinking about aging in place or just want a bathroom that actually works for your daily routine, this conversion might be exactly what you need.
If you’re seriously considering this project, working with the Best Bathroom Remodeling Services in McHenry IL can help you navigate the process from start to finish. But first, let’s break down everything you should know before making this decision.
When Does a Tub-to-Shower Conversion Actually Make Sense?
Not every bathroom is right for this conversion. And not every homeowner needs one. So how do you know if it’s the right move for you?
Your Bathtub Gets Zero Use
Be honest with yourself. When’s the last time anyone in your house took an actual bath? If it’s been months (or years), that tub is basically wasted square footage. Showers are quicker, use less water, and fit better with how most of us actually live.
Mobility Is Becoming a Concern
Stepping over a high tub wall gets harder as we age. It’s just a fact. Walk-in showers with low or zero thresholds are way safer. And if you’re planning to stay in your home long-term, this kind of accessibility upgrade is a smart investment now.
Your Bathroom Feels Cramped
Standard tubs eat up a lot of floor space. Removing one can completely transform how your bathroom feels. Even in the same footprint, a walk-in shower often makes the room seem bigger and more open.
You Want a More Modern Look
Let’s face it — those old fiberglass tub-shower combos look dated. A custom walk-in shower with tile walls and glass doors? That’s a whole different vibe. It instantly updates the entire bathroom.
What Happens During the Conversion Process
Understanding what’s involved helps you plan better and set realistic expectations. Here’s a breakdown of the typical steps.
Demolition and Removal
First, the old tub has to come out. This sounds simple but can get complicated depending on your setup. Cast iron tubs are heavy and sometimes need to be cut apart. Fiberglass units are lighter but often have walls that need removal too. Expect some dust and noise during this phase.
Plumbing Modifications
Your tub drain and shower drain sit in different spots. So the plumbing needs to be reconfigured. This usually means moving the drain location and adjusting supply lines. It’s not a huge deal for experienced contractors, but it does require cutting into the subfloor.
Waterproofing the Space
This step is absolutely non-negotiable. Showers produce way more water spray than tubs. The walls and floor need proper waterproof membranes before any tile goes up. Skip this step and you’re looking at mold problems down the road. Bathroom Remodeling Services in McHenry IL professionals know this is where quality really matters.
Installing the Shower Base
You’ve got options here. Pre-formed acrylic bases are affordable and quick to install. Tile floors look amazing but cost more and take longer. Some homeowners go with linear drains for a sleek, modern appearance. Each choice affects the overall budget and timeline.
Wall Finishing and Fixtures
Tile is the most popular choice for shower walls. Subway tile, large format porcelain, natural stone — the options are pretty much endless. Then comes the showerhead, controls, and any extras like built-in niches or benches. This is where you can really customize the space to fit your style.
Design Options That Actually Add Value
Not all walk-in showers are created equal. Some features are worth the extra investment.
Frameless Glass Enclosures
These make your bathroom look bigger and more upscale. Yeah, they cost more than framed doors. But the clean lines and easy maintenance justify the price for most homeowners.
Built-In Bench Seating
A small bench adds function without taking much space. It’s great for shaving legs, sitting while you shower, or just storing products. Professionals like Midwest General Contractor Company LLC often recommend this as a worthwhile upgrade, especially for aging-in-place projects.
Multiple Showerheads
A rain head overhead plus a handheld unit gives you flexibility. The handheld is especially useful for rinsing off and cleaning the shower itself. It’s a small splurge that makes daily showers way more enjoyable.
Recessed Storage Niches
Built-in niches keep your shampoo bottles off the floor without adding clunky corner caddies. Plan their placement carefully — you want them at convenient heights and away from direct water spray.
Cost Expectations and Timeline
Alright, let’s talk money. Because that’s what everyone really wants to know.
A basic tub-to-shower conversion typically runs between $3,000 and $8,000. That gets you a standard acrylic base, basic tile walls, and simple fixtures. Nothing fancy but functional and clean.
Mid-range conversions fall in the $8,000 to $15,000 range. You’re looking at better tile, frameless glass, upgraded fixtures, and maybe a built-in bench or niche. This is where most homeowners land.
High-end projects can exceed $20,000. Custom tile work, natural stone, multiple showerheads, heated floors, and premium glass enclosures all add up fast. But the results are stunning.
Timeline wise, plan for about one to two weeks for most conversions. Complex projects or custom work might stretch to three weeks. The Best Bathroom Remodeling Services in McHenry IL can give you a more accurate estimate based on your specific plans.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Some homeowners learn these lessons the hard way. You don’t have to.
- Skimping on waterproofing: This always backfires. Water damage repairs cost way more than doing it right the first time.
- Choosing the wrong size: Showers should be at least 36 inches square for comfort. Bigger is better if you have the space.
- Forgetting about ventilation: Walk-in showers produce humidity. Make sure your exhaust fan can handle the extra moisture.
- Ignoring resale impact: If you have only one bathroom, removing the only tub can hurt resale value. Families with young kids want at least one tub in the house.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will removing my bathtub hurt my home’s resale value?
It depends on your situation. Homes with multiple bathrooms won’t suffer much since buyers usually want at least one tub. But if it’s your only bathroom, keeping a tub option might be smarter for resale purposes.
How long does a typical tub-to-shower conversion take?
Most projects finish within one to two weeks. The exact timeline depends on complexity, material availability, and whether any unexpected issues pop up during demolition. Custom tile work adds extra time.
Can I do a tub-to-shower conversion myself?
Technically yes, but it’s risky. Plumbing modifications and proper waterproofing require skill. Mistakes lead to leaks and water damage that cost thousands to fix. Bathroom Remodeling Services in McHenry IL handle these details properly.
What’s the most affordable walk-in shower option?
Pre-fabricated shower kits with acrylic bases and wall panels offer the lowest cost. They’re not as custom-looking as tile but they’re functional, waterproof, and budget-friendly. Great for rental properties or tight budgets.
Do walk-in showers need a door?
Not always. Doorless or curbless designs are popular and make the space feel more open. They work best in larger bathrooms where water spray won’t reach other fixtures. For more ideas on bathroom updates, you can explore additional resources on home improvement projects.
